Page 3 of 3
Re: Hard pruning Acer palmatum
Posted: August 1st, 2010, 6:50 pm
by anttal63
Jarrod wrote:Yeah I was thinking about a single trunk line but I think this guy will be grown similar to the famous Walter Pall multiple trunk tree. I'm sure you know the one.
But thanks for your opinion.
Cheers.
Yes i know the one and this definately has the potential to come out like that if left in its current state.

Re: Hard pruning Acer palmatum
Posted: August 2nd, 2010, 7:04 am
by craigw60
Hi Ant I think there would be a real danger of the tree dying back down to the roots with such large cuts so low down on the tree, I know what you mean about a single trunk but that would entail some pretty major pruning. I would cut all the trunks as low as possible create a new leader on each of them and then spend some years growing the new trunklines.
Maybe I am too rough with my trees but I have had some die back on palmatums after really hard pruning.
Craig
Re: Hard pruning Acer palmatum
Posted: August 2nd, 2010, 7:37 am
by anttal63
craigw60 wrote:Hi Ant I think there would be a real danger of the tree dying back down to the roots with such large cuts so low down on the tree,
I understand now but i cant see it happening if done the right time of the year.( As soon as leaves drop, nice clean cuts, even carved and then sealed well) I know what you mean about a single trunk but that would entail some pretty major pruning. I would cut all the trunks as low as possible create a new leader on each of them and then spend some years growing the new trunklines.
Thats what i would do too, especially when you are younger than Walter Pall and could do it better! Just because he has won competitions doesnt mean it cant be improved upon! Maybe I am too rough with my trees but I have had some die back on palmatums after really hard pruning.
GO hard or go home i say Craig!
Craig
Re: Hard pruning Acer palmatum
Posted: August 2nd, 2010, 8:39 am
by craigw60
I am probably a bit old fashioned but I still look to the Japanese for inspiration, I was thinking of those big tall soft tapered multi trunk palmatums with a massive slab for nebari. With the correct root work you could achieve something close to that look with this tree.
Craig