Page 1 of 1
					
				Bookleaf Pine (I think)
				Posted: April 17th, 2017, 7:26 pm
				by [ Kane ]
				I picked up this little pine today. Ideas & thoughts?
It's obviously been cut back. I reckon that is what makes it neat.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
			 
			
					
				Re: Bookleaf Pine (I think)
				Posted: April 17th, 2017, 8:40 pm
				by Theodore
				Really, truely and brutally......it's hideous, mostly dead and good for practicing on. Not sure what, but I'm sure you can practice something 

 
			 
			
					
				Re: Bookleaf Pine (I think)
				Posted: April 17th, 2017, 10:36 pm
				by Max
				looks like a thuja of some sort... i picked 2 up from the side of the road, they looked like they had been there for a few days, so into the boot of my missus's new car they went  

 OH DIDN"T I COP AN EAR FULL  
  
 anyway  

 i potted them and have been practising things like branch selection and using my tools. My side cutter is about to get thrown over the fence but my knob cutter  
  
 both from THAT PLACE. I've read that their not handy as Bonsai because of their verticle/coarse foliage, but in saying that, i have also read a few people grafting onto them, which is what i can also practise if the poor things survive my brutality  

 
			 
			
					
				Re: Bookleaf Pine (I think)
				Posted: April 18th, 2017, 6:00 am
				by [ Kane ]
				Sir Theodore wrote:Really, truely and brutally......it's hideous, mostly dead and good for practicing on. Not sure what, but I'm sure you can practice something 

 
Haha. Thanks for your honesty.
no idea wrote:looks like a thuja of some sort... i picked 2 up from the side of the road, they looked like they had been there for a few days, so into the boot of my missus's new car they went  

 OH DIDN"T I COP AN EAR FULL  
  
 anyway  

 i potted them and have been practising things like branch selection and using my tools. My side cutter is about to get thrown over the fence but my knob cutter  
  
 both from THAT PLACE. I've read that their not handy as Bonsai because of their verticle/coarse foliage, but in saying that, i have also read a few people grafting onto them, which is what i can also practise if the poor things survive my brutality  

 
I'll give it a go. Thanks
 
			 
			
					
				Re: Bookleaf Pine (I think)
				Posted: April 18th, 2017, 10:26 am
				by treeman
				This is another plant which you should not waste precious time on. It will never amount to anything. Even just looking at it will depress your enthusiasm.
Just being realistic here. Get some nice inspiring material.
			 
			
					
				Re: Bookleaf Pine (I think)
				Posted: April 18th, 2017, 10:50 am
				by Matthew
				treeman wrote:This is another plant which you should not waste precious time on. It will never amount to anything. Even just looking at it will depress your enthusiasm.
Just being realistic here. Get some nice inspiring material.
Totally agree with Mike, if your new than try to find material that makes suitable bonsai material. These do not- its just the nature of that species. Play with something more suitable and more forgiving ie chinese elms, figs, trident maples, some junipers if you like conifers. Try to get the best material you are willing to spend on be it several cheaper trees so you get to play with them more often compared to one expensive one. Not trying to burst your bubble just a bit of advise 
