Page 1 of 1

Portulacaria ... Forest... Nigel

Posted: July 22nd, 2019, 9:48 pm
by MJL
Ok - I might get rubbished for this post. Go easy - I'll provide some warnings first so people can switch off if they desire.
  • Some on this forum are not big on forest plantings and landscapes.... this video is that.
  • Some are not fond of Portulacaria (which I think is Jade) and I have seen some robust debates about jade as bonsai...
  • Some prefer other bonsai channels than Nigel's Bonsai Zone.
Personally I think this is quite an instructive video for those interested in forest plantings and how to arrange plants for perspective.

So "Here I go" ....see what I did there. (That's Nigel's saying ;) )

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQd-ikvB4mc

For those that do watch - enjoy. Not so much exciting as helpful. This is part two ... ya probably don't need part one. Up to you.

Re: Portulacaria ... Forest... Nigel

Posted: July 22nd, 2019, 10:07 pm
by TimS
Some of his trees and plantings I actually quite like (larch group probably the main one, his Austrian Pine too would be nice with better refinement I believe).

I definitely fall into the category of disliking portulacaria both as bonsai and just generally. With the limitations of Canada though, and his....err.....enthusiasm for tropical plants, one must allow that the options are limited.

I’m surprised he gets pretty good growth given his tropicals are packed in pot tight to a conservatory/ greenhouse for what must be the best part of 6 months of the year, and his “growing” season outdoors incredibly short.

I like his enthusiastic approach, it keeps me grounded in a hobby that can be a bit serious. Sure the quality of his trees doesn’t match the amount of time he puts into them yet (he keeps doing those big trunk chops) but it reminds me to stop and just enjoy my trees some days when I’m feeling a bit confused or uninspired.