Thanks for bringing up the topic Lindsey, I think it can generate some healthy debate. I was drawn by the title of the thread, and I thought it would be an appropriate forum to address an issue on my mind of late regarding the next generation of bonsai practitioners.
Let me lead the discussion to the side for a moment. I like the idea of a TV series, and have found your shows to be both inspiring and educational. But in my opinion, the main focus of the new generation of bonsai practitioners should be to raise the standard of Australian bonsai across the board, to catch up to the great leaps that Europe and North America have experienced over the last few years in the field of bonsai. If you have been following the international scene you will have noticed a young generation of artists emerge. Young people producing astounding quality bonsai in very short time. I have asked myself what is the difference between what I see happening overseas, and what I see happening in the scene here in Australia. In my opinion it is the focus on quality raw material. I believe it is the key to progress.
Being a bonsai forum/blog fiend for several years now, I am often scouring the internet for bonsai inspiration. I have been truly impressed by some of the progress that has happened by following some European artists, and seeing the quality of young bonsai practitioners emerging from the States and Europe. In a very short amount of time they have been producing incredible bonsai. One lesson that I have learnt and realised is that bonsai does not need to be a painstakingly long process which only bears fruit from the efforts put in over 10 year +. This is a misconception that haunts people getting into the hobby, very often scares people off, and/or leaves them disinterested very quickly. For people to feel like they can access this great hobby, they must realize that great bonsai are an attainable reality. That they too can possess and create inspiring trees.
I would like to quote Walter Pall, which I took from a profile of one of his trees on his website, a Japanese maple raised from nursery material over the period of 25 years. Walter writes
“The aim is to present a bonsai in the end that looks like it grew like this by itslelf. Mother nature did it - this is what the viewer should believe. But this is not reached by letting mother nature work. It is reached by working mostly against the wish of mother nature and partially with it. On this particular maple in the end nothing grew by itself. Every single bit is made. But one can only work with what one has. If the material is lousy the result will most probably not be good. Or it will take extremely long. The maple in question could have been made from much better material in maybe five years. Or in the same time a world class tree could have been made from better material. This is what I am trying to get through here.”
He concludes by saying “DON'T WASTE 25 YEARS! DO NOT REPEAT WHAT I DID HERE! GO FROM MUCH BETTER QUALITY AT THE OUTSET. BONSAI IS NOT THE ART TO FIND VERY INEXPENSIVE MATERIAL AND MAKE A MASTERPIECE FROM IT!”
Walter may be straight in his wording, but I think it is a valuable lesson. To raise the overall quality of bonsai, we must raise the quality of the raw material, and this is not a lesson learnt in a book or a classroom about Bonsai rules of styling, it is in a lesson of where and how to find incredible raw material, how to retrieve it, then how to turn it into inspiring bonsai which is WORLD CLASS. I think this is a key lesson which must be taught, and embraced to progress.
Creating incredible bonsai does not have to be a long process. If we look at a couple from Croatia who have recently emerged as fantastic artists and collectors, Marija Hajdic & Andrija Zokic of the anima bonsai blog (
http://www.animabonsai.com/ ). This is a pair who have fully embraced this lesson, and in a few years have produced award winning, world class bonsai. Take for instance their Pistacia lentiscus which was awarded an award for native tree in natural style at the Bonsai Autumn 7 exhibition in Switzerland this year. This tree was trained only 2 years! How did they do it?! They chose exceptional raw material to start with. Please see the progress of the tree here (
http://www.animabonsai.com/pistacia-len ... ic-tree-2/ ). But looking through the gallery of bonsai on their site, one will see that the standard of their trees is exceptional, and that they are excelling by only using great raw material. But what is most astounding is that they are taking native species and creating their own style, and in the process creating a national profile for the species and the artists. We can do the same!
If we look at the variety of material available on our doorstep yet to be explored thoroughly. Callitris, Athrotaxis, Casuarina, Callistimon, Melaleuca the list goes on! We need not look far for inspiring natural setting for inspiration. It is everywhere. And so is the material! We must embrace our local plant species and make use of them, and show the world that Australia shines on a world scale.
We must respect the roots of bonsai and the traditional teachings, but the only way forward is to step up, and dig! Too often I am frustrated by the nursery material that so many people are using to create bonsai. Having started myself through this type of material, I do not blame them, because it is an accessible way to access the hobby, but will leave you unsatisfied, and disinterested very quickly. Every now and then one may find something neat, but we need game changers. This is partly due to traditional teachings of bonsai, and the lack of focus on material to start with.
We need to stress that bonsai of great quality is attainable in short time, by using the right material to start with in the first place. Also we need to stress that Australian species have fantastic bonsai potential, and I admire the efforts gone to by this forum particularly in spreading this message. To lift the standard here we need the same quality of material found at current European and American exhibitions. One is astounded at the quality of trees displayed at the Neolanders and such events. But one thing is for sure, they weren’t grown from a straight piece of nursery material.
We need a generation of diggers. People keen to get out there, put in the hours, get their hands dirty and source the material that is going to lift Australia into the scene. There are inspiring artists and collectors amongst us, but we need to step up and lift Australia like others have lifted the States and Europe, like the Ryan Neils, the Andrija and Marijas etc.
So I put it forward to you, let’s show the world that Australia can compete on the world stage.