Cotoneaster critique please.

Post your bonsai for critique by members. Virtual designs and restyles are encouraged.
Post Reply
User avatar
Mitchell
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Posts: 1807
Joined: February 15th, 2010, 4:34 pm
Favorite Species: Ficus
Bonsai Age: 1
Bonsai Club: [color=#FFFF00]Aus[/color][color=#40FF40]Bonsai[/color]
Location: Sydney,Beecroft

Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by Mitchell »

Hi!

Have recently been doing some work on a plant of mine. Generally trying to increase taper and work on the Jin / deadwood.
Was interested to see if you thought there was a future in this plant as a good Bonsai.
What would you change or think is good at the moment.

This si directly after a major prune back, so it appear sparse atm.

Any comments and critique welcomed as I would like some input to its future.

Thanks! :)
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Regards, Mitchell.



"It is one thing to shape a tree into form, but when you are able to convincingly deceive ones perception of reality, something much more is accomplished than just a simple bonsai."

"In a perfect world, we would all be giants and all plants Bonsai."

"Grow big, finish small."


Image Join Ausbonsai today Click Here! Image
craigw60
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Posts: 1904
Joined: January 12th, 2010, 12:02 pm
Favorite Species: many
Bonsai Age: 25
Bonsai Club: yarra valley
Location: vic
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by craigw60 »

Hi Dragon,
You are leaving your trees too tall if you cut them way down you will in the long term have much better bonsai.
Craig
Watto
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Posts: 3975
Joined: July 6th, 2009, 8:17 am
Favorite Species: Plum
Bonsai Age: 0
Bonsai Club: Goulburn Bonsai Society
Location: Goulburn
Has thanked: 556 times
Been thanked: 1149 times

Re: Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by Watto »

Hi CD and it is good to see you posting a few items for us to look at. Don't want to be harsh but the photos are very difficult to get a proper appreciation of the actual trees.
Maybe you could try a plain background. JMHO
Check out my blog at http://www.ausbonsai.com.au/blog/Watto" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
User avatar
MelaQuin
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Posts: 1340
Joined: November 7th, 2008, 2:16 pm
Favorite Species: olives & natives
Bonsai Age: 20
Bonsai Club: Illawarra Bonsai Society, Bonsai Society of A
Location: St George Area, Sydney Australia
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by MelaQuin »

I find them crammed together in a pot that is not the best for growing on or accentuating the trees. I agree with Craig's comment that they are way too tall. My suggestion would be to remove them from the pot they are in and plant them in an oval or rectangular shallow pot that allows the roots to spread across the pot and gives more soil for more growth. My tendency would be to repot then leave them until they start shooting and reduce the height. You will improve the impact of the trunks by lowering the height.
User avatar
Jamie
Bonsai passionardo
Bonsai passionardo
Posts: 6829
Joined: August 21st, 2009, 8:08 pm
Favorite Species: CLERO!!!,ficus, celtis, juniper, elms
Bonsai Age: 9
Bonsai Club: AUSBONSAI.COM
Location: queensland, Hervey Bay
Been thanked: 2 times
Contact:

Re: Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by Jamie »

as much as it has been said already this tree needs to be shortened severely, and then regrown out, i suggest to do it in ground as it will speed the process up.
or at least a grow box.

CD can i ask how long you have been playing around with bonsai? and do you have any experience with growing trees? i only ask as the couple of trees you have posted are kind of a worry, speaking from my experience i was so keen when i first started bonsai to get trees in pots i didnt realise that there was so much more to bonsai than having a tree in a pot, over the past few years this concept changed, i started realising that i needed to get stock that had been grown out (more advanced), and even then most of the trees i aquired had to be chopped down, this also applies to ground grown trees, yamadori.

as you have dug both trees you have posted this is a good thing as you have had some ground growth on the tree, once lifted it shouldnt really have any work on it apart from the roots cleaning them out of old soil and replacing with fresh. then if necessary top growth taken to equal out the impact of the loss of roots. then a rest period is required as the tree has gone through a lot of stress, which brings me to this question, has the two trees you posted had any of this?

the good thing is they are hardy trees to lift from the ground. once the trees have had there rest period and have started growing strong which can sometimes take 1-2 seasons of growing.
if you could chop down while in the ground to induce taper that will make the process a lot quicker, but bonsai isnt something that can really be done fast.

my advice to you is if you can join a club and learn as much as you can from people, get books and read, learn how to look after the trees as if you cant keep a tree alive then bonsai will be hard, people spend lifetimes looking after trees and growing on just for the next generation after them to work on.

im not having a crack at ya mate, your enthusiasm is great, i just think you need to start considering the trees you have dug and how they will go in these tiny pots. it does concern me is all.
keep the enthusiasm mate, keep the excitement its a good thing, you will learn every day with this art and it is very rewarding, i have been in bonsai for 5 years and i can gaurantee i will be into it for the rest of my natural life. it has taken me up to now to really appreciate the how long trees take to get to a certain stage, and the trees i had in pots 5 years ago are basically all out of pots now and in grow boxes as i dont have ground to grow in.

keep it green mate :D


jamie :D
SHOHIN YAKUZA!!!
:twisted: taking the top half of trees of since 2005! :twisted:
and growing trees for the future generations! 50+ year plans :D
User avatar
aaron_tas
HARDKNOCKSBONSAI
HARDKNOCKSBONSAI
Posts: 1067
Joined: November 13th, 2008, 3:18 pm
Favorite Species: ulmus
Bonsai Age: 100
Bonsai Club: south tas, Illawarra, Launceston
Location: Launceston
Been thanked: 2 times
Contact:

Re: Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by aaron_tas »

hi dragon :!:

i think the tree has some real potential as penjing, a tall twin trunk with lots of negative space in the pot to the right and just a few branches with movement right, and the apex of the tree to be the smaller sharp jin on the right tree...

do you need a virt of what i mean :?: orrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr......

:D
inspired by nature,
considered superior to nature.
User avatar
Mitchell
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Aussie Bonsai Fan
Posts: 1807
Joined: February 15th, 2010, 4:34 pm
Favorite Species: Ficus
Bonsai Age: 1
Bonsai Club: [color=#FFFF00]Aus[/color][color=#40FF40]Bonsai[/color]
Location: Sydney,Beecroft

Re: Cotoneaster critique please.

Post by Mitchell »

aaron_tas wrote:hi dragon :!:

i think the tree has some real potential as penjing, a tall twin trunk with lots of negative space in the pot to the right and just a few branches with movement right, and the apex of the tree to be the smaller sharp jin on the right tree...

do you need a virt of what i mean :?: orrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr......

:D

I think I follow you, a virt would be nice if it's not too much trouble. Thanks.
Regards, Mitchell.



"It is one thing to shape a tree into form, but when you are able to convincingly deceive ones perception of reality, something much more is accomplished than just a simple bonsai."

"In a perfect world, we would all be giants and all plants Bonsai."

"Grow big, finish small."


Image Join Ausbonsai today Click Here! Image
Post Reply

Return to “Critiques & Virtual Designs”